Conflicts arise between Middle Township officials and residents of Whitesboro in fear of impending tax burdens. Embedded in the embroilment is a community advocating for its survival in a heavily gentrified, southern coastal New Jersey.
Whitesboro, NJ — Middle Township held a referendum to decide whether a $26 million dollar bond should be granted to its public schools this past September. This bond was intended to fund the expansion of a preschool, an elementary school, and to pay for a football field. Voters rejected the special school measure, but there was an unwelcome consequence for a historical Black community fighting for resources in the municipality: a tax hike.
“When they made this referendum, they didn’t really have Whitesboro in mind,” says Shirley Green.
Whitesboro is a town founded by Blacks at the turn of the twentieth century. At the time of its inception, Booker T. Washington, a celebrated institution builder, educator and favored adviser to President Theodore Roosevelt, provided a blueprint to a collective of financial backers from the Colored Equitable Industrial Association. The group was started by Reverend J.W. Fishburn and four other members of Cape May City’s African Methodist Episcopal—one of them being famed Harlem Renaissance poet and writer, Paul Laurence Dunbar.
Today Green is known as the leader of Whitesboro. She is also the founder and executive director of the Whitesboro Historic Foundation and Museum, and one of the principal members of the Whitesboro Historic Preservation Project. Recently, she was a vocal opponent of the referendum.
Unlike Whitesboro’s wealthy Cape May and Wildwood Junction neighbors, their town, which still holds a strong Black representation, are mostly working class people or professionals dealing with the rising costs of living in a desired South Jersey location.
“One of the problems we had was it would have cost the people almost $167 dollars extra in taxes, in the meantime, it wasn’t addressing the other issues that was also going to come behind it like how your [home] insurance is going to increase because they’ve now changed the zoning [from rural] to coastal,” Green explains.
In order to pay for the expansion of school facilities, it would have added a heavier tax burden, which according to Green, would have been “the largest one in Cape May County.”
Asbury Park journalist and Whitesboro activist Felicia Simmons states Whitesboro holds a distinct position: “They’re the ones pretty much here 12 months of the year in the county and they bear a lot of the tax burden, but receive none of the tax benefits.”
“You have a lot of low-income people [in Whitesboro], but they are homeowners,” says Simmons.
“The burden just keeps going up and up… this is their full-time home, their community that they’ve lived in, some for generations,” Simmons adds.
The Black tax
Due to its location, and Cape May County being a popular destination for seaside resorts, a large percentage of the residents live in Middle Township part-time and own seasonal homes. On the other hand, the people of Whitesboro live there 365 days of the year. Subsequently, the increase of homeowners insurance—due to reclassified zoning—in addition to a possible referendum to increase property taxes, plays a more detrimental effect on Whitesboro residents.
According to Simmons, the decision to present a referendum was poorly thought-out and hastily put together by a council who, “didn’t do enough outreach nor enough community engagement to solve the problem.”
There are solutions that exist, as Simmons points to grant money that is put aside by the state of New Jersey for such matters. One such example is the New Jersey Debt Defeasance and Prevention Fund. But lack of communication between Middle Township and residents makes seeking out alternative options difficult to enact. Simply placing the burden on the taxpayers in the township is tone-deaf.
Or as Simmons remarks, “taxation without any representation.”
“Whitesboro gets no benefit. Their town still doesn’t have street lights, they still don’t have paved roads, they don’t have a store, they have been paying their taxes,” Simmons adds.
In fact, Shirley Green was the first person to even open a business in Whitesboro within the last 50 years. Tiffany’s Beans and Birds closed due to the Covid.
“Even if you wanted to open a business, you don’t even have the opportunity as outside businesses get all sorts of tax breaks to come in and bring their business here,” Green says.
For Green, a long-term resident and respected community member, the township made it extremely difficult for even her business to open.
“You have to factor in the legacy of racism in the township and what brought Whitesboro into existence in the first place,” says Elorm Ocansey.
Questions of foul play have been drawn in regards to the referendum and attempt to increase property taxes. Whitesboro historical preservation advocates claim that the township used early education to provoke sympathy and ultimately rush a referendum vote in September, rather than wait for the upcoming November general elections. The dubious practice reduced the amount of time people had to discuss their opinions.
Yet, this is not the first time that Middle Township and Whitesboro have been at odds with each other.
When association members established Whitesboro in 1901; after white leadership in Cape May City led a racial cleansing across the beachfront destination, the settlement was meant for Blacks leaving both, a racist Cape May City, and the domestic terrorism of the South. Whitesboro’s biggest investor, George H. White, was a former slave who rose to prominence as an attorney and a North Carolina congressman during the Reconstruction Era. He knew about racial cleansings all too well.
In 1898, while serving his first term as a senator, White received news that an organized mass of former Confederate soldiers in Wilmington, North Carolina, had successfully carried out a coup d’etat against the interracial leadership of the city. Then they enacted a massacre and a land grab that lasted for weeks, explained Sean Palmer to Ark Republic. Palmer is a resident of Wilmington, a local historian, pastor and newly minted director of YMI Black Cultural Center in Asheville, North Carolina.
The upending of Wilmington’s progressive government resulted in thousands of Black North Carolinians who survived, and those in other parts of the state signaled out as “trouble,” to flee the area. Whitesboro, New Jersey became one of the towns they found refuge years later, but it also carried a stigma because of its Black ownership.
When the Wilmington coup d’etat occurred, White was already living in Washington, DC as a banker, lawyer and politician. As the only Black representative in office, he remained in the area after his electoral career ended. When Whitesboro was founded, he was the largest landowner under his business, George H. White Land Improvement Company. Today, Shirley Green and her family own the most plots of land in the community. Now, she knows the racial complexities of the area all too well.

Middle Township, despite consisting of 15 communities stretching 75 miles and a population of 2,300, has been under the control of a few hands. Ocansey notes that, “everything happens either through the [township] council of three members who make all the decisions about the state of the town or even more so the mayor who is appointed has final say-so over everything. The business administrator sort of organizes things from top to bottom according to what the council voted for.”
“When it comes to planning and reducing the burden on residents, not just with the school district, but with everything else,” Ocansey says. “They are very lackadaisical and aren’t really committed to bringing it ratable. The township doesn’t even have a department of planning.”
As tensions continue to grow between Whitesboro and Middle Township in regards to tax burdens, the support for the incorporation of Whitesboro has continued to strengthen.
Nevertheless, the current mayor of Middle Township, Christopher Leusner, has expressed opposition to Whitesboro becoming incorporated stating “the tax bill would be astronomical.”
In response to Mayor Luesner’s statements, Ocansey argues fear of tax increases is simply an excuse being made to shut down any conversation. “To lump that in with incorporation, it’s not really an effective way to collaborate and to have a dialogue,” Ocansey offers.
Because Whitesboro lacks an official municipality designation, residents pay taxes, but receive a very limited amount of government dollars. Also, they lack government representation such as a mayor or their own council member. Consequently, they remain vulnerable to local power players and their decisions.
Ocansey also points out that “there’s a plan by the township to build a 100-acre family development.”
Middle Township’s land ownership is partially split between the township proper, an estate, and about 50 homeowners, many of whom live within Whitesboro. For Whitesboro advocates, the acquisition of homeowner’s property has become an objective for Middle Township to make this development a reality.
Despite the township claiming it wants to cooperate with its residents, many of the homeowners in Whitesboro sense that the threat of eminent domain looms. “A lot of these homes are legacy homes [that Whitesboro residents] are looking to pass onto their children,” stresses Ocansey. Eminent domain is when the government confiscates land by forcibly taking the private property of a citizen in order to convert it for public use.
Majority of Whitesboro residents are full-time homeowners which contrasts with the large and growing population of part-time homeowners found throughout Cape May County, including Middle Township. Another factor in Whitesboro residents championing incorporation, is that they have always contributed taxes which fund Middle Township’s public services, schools and infrastructure. However, it appears that the township has done little in return for its primary taxpayers.
“When we look at the history of Whitesboro, it’s been pretty much the same development-wise… unpaved roads, no streetlights and no infrastructure,” notes Simmons.
According to Simmons, Whitesboro residents have requested more development in a district that sits adjacent to the wealthy coastal community, Cape May, for decades, but appeals have been repeatedly rejected. Like the township’s response to their past petition for paved roads was, “‘you have to pave it yourselves.’”
In regards to the past referendum vote, the lack of engagement from Middle Township’s council and mayor has been a disappointment to Whitesboro’s activists who are hoping for an open discussion on how local schools can be aided. Simmons makes clear there are options to make early childhood education not a significant tax burden on Whitesboro, “there’s a lot of money set aside” in the state and “grant funding” that can be used.
“The school district is the arm of the community,” Simmons makes clear. She emphasizes that Whitesboro residents care about the education of children, but feel the exorbitant tax increase is not the right path. For her, the conversations can be held to find a solution to please both parties.
“These are hardworking, entrepreneurial and dedicated people who are saying they just want the right to live and raise their families without being overburdened by taxes,” says Simmons.
Kaia Niambi Shivers contributed to the historical backdrop of this piece.

Outstanding Read. Extremely informative and very well written!!!!
Very interesting story.